πŸ¦‹Caterpillar 2 Butterfly
← Back to Journal
🌟 Emerging Leaders3 min read

Starting Out as a Leader: The One Thing Most New Leaders Get Wrong

By Selina Boshorin Β· Caterpillar 2 Butterfly

When you step into a leadership role for the first time, the pressure to have all the answers is immense. But the most effective new leaders don't have all the answers β€” they ask better questions.

The Answers Trap

New leaders often believe their credibility depends on having answers. They feel they need to project confidence, certainty, and expertise at all times. Admitting uncertainty feels like weakness. Asking questions feels like exposing gaps.

But this belief β€” that leadership means having all the answers β€” is one of the most limiting things a new leader can carry. It leads to poor decisions (made without enough information), disengaged teams (who don't feel heard), and exhausted leaders (carrying a weight they don't need to carry alone).

The Power of Questions

The most effective leaders I've worked with β€” at every level β€” are exceptional questioners. They ask before they advise. They listen before they decide. They create space for others to think, rather than filling every silence with their own perspective.

This isn't passivity. It's strategic. When you ask good questions, you gather better information. You build trust and psychological safety. You develop the people around you. And you make better decisions β€” because they're informed by more perspectives than just your own.

Questions Every New Leader Should Ask

  • 1.What does success look like in this role β€” from the perspective of the people I serve?
  • 2.What do my team need from me that they're not currently getting?
  • 3.What are the unspoken rules and dynamics I need to understand?
  • 4.Where am I making assumptions that I should be testing?
  • 5.Who can I learn from β€” inside and outside this organisation?
  • 6.What would I do differently if I wasn't afraid of getting it wrong?

The Shift That Changes Everything

When new leaders shift from β€œI need to have the answers” to β€œI need to ask better questions,” something changes. The pressure lifts. The team engages. The decisions improve. And the leader grows faster β€” because they're learning from everyone around them, not just from their own experience.

Just stepping into leadership?

Leadership Foundations is designed for exactly where you are. Book a free discovery call to find out more.